| 1 | Oak Knoll School | Summit, New Jersey | 26-0-0 | 1 | Tournament of Champions Winner, Non-Public State Champions |
| 2 | Eastern Regional High School | Voorhees, New Jersey | 23-2-0 | 2 | Tournament of Champions Runner-Up, Group 4 State Champions |
| 3 | Frank W. Cox High School | Virginia Beach, Virginia | 21-1-0 | 4 | Class 5 State Champions, 5A Regional Champions |
| 4 | Episcopal Academy | Newtown Square, Pennsylvania | 20-1-1 | 12 | PAISAA Champions, Inter-AC Champions |
| 5 | Wilson High School | West Lawn, Pennsylvania | 25-3-0 | 9 | AAA State Champions, District III AAA Runner-Up |
| 6 | Lower Dauphin High School | Hummelstown, Pennsylvania | 23-1-3 | 3 | AAA State Runner-Up, District III AAA Champions |
| 7 | Delmar High School | Delmar, Delaware | 19-0-0 | 6 | Division 2 State Champions |
| 8 | West Essex High School | Caldwell, New Jersey | 23-2-1 | 8 | Group 2 State Champions, TOC Semifinalist |
| 9 | The Hill School | Pottstown, Pennsylvania | 17-3-0 | 10 | PAISAA Runner-Up, MAPL Champions |
| 10 | Wyoming Seminary | Kingston, Pennsylvania | 23-2-0 | 23 | A State Champions, District II A Champions |
| 11 | Sacred Heart Greenwich | Greenwich, Connecticut | 20-2-0 | 13 | NEPSAC A Champions, FAA Regular Season Champions, FAA Tournament Runner-Up |
| 12 | New Trier High School | Winnetka, Illinois | 29-2-1 | 14 | Illinois State Champions |
| 13 | Trinity Episcopal School | Richmond, Virginia | 21-0-0 | 15 | VISAA Division I State Champions |
| 14 | Wyoming Valley West High School | Plymouth, Pennsylvania | 16-3-1 | NR | AA State Champions, District II 2A Champions |
| 15 | Palmyra Area High School | Palmyra, Pennsylvania | 22-4-0 | 5 | AA State Runner-Up, District III AA Champions |
| 16 | Oley Valley High School | Oley, Pennsylvania | 25-2-0 | 7 | A State Runner-Up, District III A Runner-Up |
| 17 | Emmaus High School | Emmaus, Pennsylvania | 26-1-0 | 16 | AAA State Semifinalist, District XI AAA Champions |
| 18 | Hershey High School | Hershey, Pennsylvania | 18-7-0 | 11 | AAA State Semifinalist, District III AAA Semifinalist, 3rd Place through Playbacks |
| 19 | Somerset Berkley Regional High School | Somerset, Massachusetts | 24-0-0 | 20 | Division 1 State Champions |
| 20 | Lakeland High School | Shrub Oak, New York | 20-1-1 | 19 | NYS Class A State Champions |
| 21 | Greenwood High School | Millerstown, Pennsylvania | 19-2-2 | NR | A State Semifinalist, District III A Champions |
| 22 | Kingsway Regional High School | Woolwich Township, New Jersey | 20-1-1 | 21 | South Jersey Group 4 Runner-Up |
| 23 | Greenwich Academy | Greenwich, Connecticut | 17-3-2 | 17 | NEPSAC A Quarterfinalist, FAA Tournament Champions |
| 24 | Maine-Endwell High School | Endwell, New York | 16-3-0 | NR | NYS Class A State Champions |
| 25 | Garrison Forest School | Owings Mills, Maryland | 17-3-1 | NR | IAAM A Conference Champions |
2019 HIGH SCHOOL FINAL
